UMVA has learned that a Florida couple, Tiffany Score and Steven Mills, have reached a custody agreement with the biological parents of their child, Shea, after a remarkable IVF mix-up.
The extraordinary case began when an embryo belonging to another couple was implanted during IVF treatment in 2025, resulting in the birth of Shea in December of that year. Score and Mills, who are white, had expected a child biologically theirs, but DNA results later revealed that Shea's genetic parents were a South Asian couple.
As the situation unfolded, both families faced an agonizing reality: one couple had raised Shea from birth, while the other had unknowingly lost the chance to carry and bring up their biological daughter. The case sparked a custody dispute, with questions surrounding whether biology or the bond formed between a child and caregivers should determine custody.
According to information obtained by UMVA, the biological parents ultimately chose not to pursue a custody fight, citing concerns about the potential impact on Shea. Their lawyer described them as 'heartbroken' by the situation, but willing to prioritize Shea's well-being over their own desires.
The agreement allows Score and Mills to remain Shea's long-term parents, with both families expressing a desire to foster a relationship of friendship and trust. The biological parents' lawyer described the discussions between the families as involving 'a lot of tears and hugs' as they worked towards a mutually acceptable solution.
The case has led to multiple lawsuits against the Fertility Center of Orlando, including allegations that the wrong embryo was implanted during treatment. The clinic has announced plans to close, citing 'thoughtful consideration.' Court documents reveal that Score and Mills have transferred their remaining embryo to a different fertility clinic for testing and evaluation.
As the situation continues to unfold, both families appear to be focusing on Shea's future and what's best for her. The resolution of the custody dispute brings a sense of closure, but the emotional impact of the IVF mix-up will likely be felt for years to come.
