The body of Sonia Exelby was recovered on October 17 in a woodland area near Marion Oaks, Florida, by U.S. investigators.
Exelby, a 32‑year‑old from Southsea, Portsmouth, Hampshire, had been reported missing on October 12 after failing to return from a trip to the United States.
She was the youngest of six siblings and was described by her family as gentle, compassionate, and deeply loved. Her talent included piano playing and singing, and she was noted for her calm presence and affectionate nature.
Exelby had left the United Kingdom on October 10, arriving in Florida for a short stay. She was scheduled to return three days later but did not board the flight.
Her long‑term partner posted an emotional appeal, suggesting she might have arranged a meeting that placed her in a vulnerable situation.
U.S. detectives indicated that Exelby had traveled with the intention of meeting online individuals who could potentially harm her. Computer evidence suggested she was suicidal and feared sexual abuse, torture, or murder by unknown parties.
Dwain Hall was arrested on charges of first‑degree murder and kidnapping in connection with the case.
Investigators recovered a shovel from Hall’s home that contained soil matching samples from the burial site, and blood was found on the handle. The shovel was identified as a key piece of evidence linking Hall to the crime scene.
A post‑mortem revealed that Exelby had been stabbed four times. The cause of death was determined to be homicide by stabbing.
Hampshire police confirmed receiving a missing person report on the day of Exelby’s disappearance and noted that she had traveled outside the United Kingdom before the report was filed.
The police are continuing to support the investigation led by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, providing assistance to Exelby’s family in the United Kingdom.
The case remains under active investigation, with authorities seeking further evidence to clarify the circumstances surrounding Exelby’s death.
