A wave of outrage is sweeping through Florida following the tragic death of five-year-old Missy Mogle, and Governor Ron DeSantis is demanding accountability – starting with the judge he believes allowed her killer to remain free.
DeSantis recently signed into law measures designed to increase crime accountability, but his strongest words were reserved for Judge Tiffany Baker-Carper. He publicly urged the Florida House to impeach her, citing her decision to release convicted sex offender Daniel Spencer on bond prior to sentencing.
Spencer, already convicted in an underage sex sting, was later charged – alongside Chloe Spencer – in Missy Mogle’s alleged murder. The state is now seeking the death penalty in a case DeSantis calls an “outrage” and a direct consequence of a judicial failure.
The governor didn’t mince words, stating that Judge Baker-Carper knowingly took a risk by releasing Spencer, a risk that tragically resulted in a young girl’s death. He believes the legislature possesses the power – and the numbers – to remove her from the bench.
“Until you start holding these judges accountable,” DeSantis declared, “they are going to continue to find ways to benefit the criminal element.” He suggested that even some Democrats might support impeachment given the horrific circumstances of the case.
Judge Baker-Carper, elected in 2020 as the youngest woman and youngest Black person to hold a judgeship in Florida’s 2nd Judicial Circuit, allowed Spencer to remain free despite his conviction. This decision is now at the center of a firestorm of criticism.
The newly signed “Missy’s Law” directly addresses the concerns raised by this case. It mandates that defendants convicted of dangerous crimes be held in custody pending sentencing, removing judicial discretion in these instances.
DeSantis believes the law, while significant, isn’t enough. He insists the legislature must also act to hold Judge Baker-Carper accountable, establishing a clear check and balance to prevent similar tragedies in the future.
Alongside Missy’s Law, DeSantis also signed House Bill 1159, which strengthens protections for children and increases penalties related to child sexual abuse material. The legislation expands the definition of “dangerous crimes” to include certain computer pornography offenses.
Attorney General James Uthmeier emphasized that Missy’s Law removes judicial discretion, ensuring that dangerous criminals are incarcerated after conviction. He expressed gratitude to DeSantis for signing the bill into law, a direct response to the devastating loss of Missy Mogle.
DeSantis framed these actions as a firm commitment to law and order in Florida, vowing to protect children and deliver justice for victims of crime. He believes swift and meaningful consequences are essential for those who prey on the innocent.
The governor’s actions signal a clear message: Florida will not tolerate judicial decisions that jeopardize public safety, and those responsible will be held accountable to the fullest extent of the law.
