A chilling scene unfolded Monday before the North Carolina General Assembly, revealing a startling lack of basic civic knowledge from an elected official entrusted with public safety. Mecklenburg County Sheriff Garry McFadden faced intense questioning, and the results were deeply unsettling.
The interrogation centered on critical issues within his jurisdiction, including concerns surrounding immigration policies and a series of deaths occurring within the county jails under his leadership. Lawmakers relentlessly pressed McFadden on his handling of these sensitive matters, particularly the tragic murder of Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska.
The hearing took a dramatically uncomfortable turn when State Representative Allen Chesser decided to assess McFadden’s understanding of the fundamental structure of American government. The question was deceptively simple: under which branch of government does the Sheriff’s office operate?
McFadden’s response was not only incorrect, but repeatedly so. He initially stated “Mecklenburg County,” then pivoted to “the U.S. Constitution,” demonstrating a profound disconnect from the core principles of governance. The sheriff appeared unable to grasp the basic framework of power.
Chesser patiently attempted to guide McFadden, even asking how many branches of government exist. The sheriff admitted he didn’t know. Chesser then clearly outlined the three branches – Legislative, Executive, and Judicial – and presented the question again, essentially offering a multiple-choice option.
Despite this assistance, McFadden remained stubbornly incorrect. He insisted his department fell under the judicial branch, a fundamental mischaracterization of a law enforcement agency’s role. The exchange highlighted a disturbing gap in understanding for someone holding such a powerful position.
Finally, Chesser delivered the blunt truth. He explained that McFadden’s office was a constitutional office with inherent responsibilities, and unequivocally stated that it operated under the executive branch. The moment hung heavy with implications about preparedness and competence.
The transcript of the exchange reveals the stark reality:
CHESSER: What branch of government do you operate under?
MCFADDEN: Mecklenburg County.
CHESSER: Are you aware of how many branches of government there are?
MCFADDEN: No.
CHESSER: Of those three, which do you believe you fall under?
MCFADDEN: I believe I fall under the last one.
CHESSER: You are incorrect, sir. You fall under the executive.
The incident raises serious questions about the qualifications and understanding of those entrusted with upholding the law and protecting communities. It’s a stark reminder of the importance of civic literacy, even – and perhaps especially – for elected officials.
