UMVA has learned that a dramatic revelation about Canada's efforts to combat antisemitism has left many questioning the effectiveness of the government's new approach.
Prime Minister Mark Carney's announcement on Monday about a council to tackle antisemitism was not the groundbreaking move many thought it was. In reality, the council had been established months ago, with a broader focus on fostering community and civic engagement.
The real news was the addition of Marc Gold, who brings a Jewish perspective to the council. However, Gold's recent retirement as a senator appointed by former Liberal Prime Minister Justin Trudeau raises questions about his independence in criticizing the government.
The council's seven members, including former Liberal MP Omar Alghabra, have impressive backgrounds but lack direct experience in fighting antisemitism. Alghabra, a past critic of Israel and self-described defender of Palestinian rights, has sparked concerns about his suitability for the task.
Carney's government has been criticized for its handling of antisemitism, including a 'Muslim values are Canadian values' approach and an arms embargo on Israel. The Prime Minister's own performance on combatting antisemitism has also been called into question.
The council's task is daunting: to reassess the nature and scale of antisemitism in Canada, develop a whole-of-government approach, and improve research and data collection on hate incidents. But with members like Alghabra and a lack of clear expertise, many are skeptical about their ability to succeed.
Opposition Leader Pierre Poilievre has expressed doubts about Alghabra's appointment, recalling how he lobbied to keep Hezbollah legal. The council's credibility has been further eroded by concerns about its members' connections and motivations.
As Canada's Jewish community faces a crisis of antisemitism, many are wondering if this council is equipped to tackle the problem. With supporters of Hamas and Gaza terrorists active on Canadian soil, the stakes are high, and the government's response will be closely watched.
The focus should be on concrete actions, such as encouraging police to make arrests in antisemitic incidents and deporting those who hate Israel and Jews. But with this council's limitations, many fear that the government's efforts will fall short.
